Summary: Both ICL and LASIK are advanced vision correction procedures designed to reduce or eliminate dependence on glasses and contact lenses. While LASIK reshapes the cornea using laser technology, ICL involves implanting a lens inside the eye. Understanding the ICL vs LASIK surgery differences, including cost, recovery, and suitability, can help you make the right choice for long-term eye health.
|
Key Takeaways:
|
Understanding ICL vs LASIK Surgery
The human eye plays a crucial role in our ability to see, interpret shapes, and perceive colour and depth. However, vision issues like myopia (nearsightedness), hyperopia (farsightedness), and astigmatism can affect clarity.
Modern medical advancements now offer two major options to correct these refractive errors — ICL and LASIK surgery. Let’s explore ICL vs LASIK to understand which one is better suited to your eye condition.
What Is ICL (Implantable Collamer Lens)?
ICL eye surgery is a refractive procedure that uses a biocompatible synthetic lens similar to a contact lens. This lens is surgically placed in front of the eye’s natural lens and behind the iris, making it invisible to both the patient and others.
- The ICL lens enhances vision without removing corneal tissue.
- It is removable and reversible, offering flexibility.
- Ideal for people with thin corneas or dry eye syndrome, where LASIK may not be recommended.
Thus, ICL is considered a safe and effective alternative to LASIK, especially for individuals not suited for corneal laser surgery.
What Is LASIK?
LASIK (Laser-Assisted In Situ Keratomileusis) is a laser-based refractive surgery that reshapes the cornea to correct vision errors.
- A flap is created on the corneal surface using a laser.
- The cornea is reshaped to improve how light focuses on the retina.
- Commonly used to correct myopia, hypermetropia, and astigmatism.
LASIK remains one of the most widely performed vision correction procedures worldwide due to its quick results and short recovery time.
Advantages And Disadvantages
Lasik
This straightforward laser-based method has helped millions of people worldwide see better, proving that it works well. Certain side effects can negatively affect your life, but they are usually small and go away as your body heals.
Pros
- LASIK is rapid and reasonably priced.
- You will spend roughly 30 minutes in your eye doctor’s office if you need to fix both eyes.
- Because LASIK is becoming more popular and less expensive overall, it is a cost-effective procedure. Your vision insurance may cover a portion of the cost.
Cons
- There is a possibility of experiencing adverse effects for six months.
- Halos or glares around lights, dry eyes, and impaired night vision are possible side effects; however, these usually go away within a few months of surgery.
- Since LASIK is regarded as one of the safest surgical procedures, serious problems are sporadic.
ICL
These are not as common as LASIK. Visian ICL can be a better choice if you aren’t a good candidate for LASIK due to certain issues.
Pros
- ICLs are a far better option than LASIK if you have thin corneas, corneal issues including keratoconus, or chronic dry eye.
- The lenses are removable should complications arise, though chances are minimal. LASIK, on the other hand, cannot be undone.
- Even though the surgical procedure for the ICL takes a little longer than LASIK—about 20 minutes for each eye—it is still a quick procedure.
Cons
- When talking about ICL vs LASIK cost, ICL is significantly more expensive than LASIK.
- You have a slightly increased risk of getting cataracts or glaucoma.
ICL vs LASIK Surgery Cost in India
When comparing ICL vs LASIK cost, ICL is usually more expensive.
- ICL cost: ₹80,000 to ₹90,000 (per eye)
- LASIK cost: ₹20,000 to ₹30,000 (per eye)
ICL’s higher cost is attributed to its use of a collamer lens and the complexity of intraocular implantation.
ICL vs LASIK Surgery: Which Is Better?
The answer to ICL vs LASIK which is better depends on individual eye conditions, corneal thickness, and lifestyle needs. The table below highlights the key differences between the two procedures to help you understand which option may be more suitable for you.
|
Basis of Difference |
ICL (Implantable Collamer Lens) |
LASIK (Laser-Assisted Surgery) |
|
UV Protection |
Yes |
No |
|
Removes Corneal Tissue |
No |
No |
|
Biocompatible Lens |
Yes |
No, as it’s laser-based reshaping |
|
Reversal or Removal |
Yes (reversible) |
Not reversible |
|
Days of Recovery |
1–2 days |
Around 2 weeks for flap healing |
|
Suitable for Thin Corneas |
Yes |
Limited suitability |
|
Contributes to Dry Eyes |
No |
Yes (up to 20%) |
|
Clarity of Vision |
Often better than LASIK |
Excellent, but not superior to ICL |
|
Procedure Type |
Intraocular (lens-based) |
Corneal (laser-based) |
|
Cost |
Higher than LASIK cost |
More affordable |
Choose LASIK if you have normal corneal thickness and want a quick, affordable solution. Choose ICL if you have thin corneas, dry eyes, or prefer a reversible procedure with sharper visual clarity. Always consult your ophthalmologist for a personalised assessment to determine the best refractive surgery option for your eyes.
Why Centre For Sight?
Get in touch with Centre for Sight if you’re interested in receiving either of the two procedures described above. Centre for Sight is committed to giving millions of individuals the freedom to live without glasses and the joy of clear eyesight to improve their quality of life. We are committed to providing our patients with the best ophthalmology care possible using the most advanced diagnostic and therapeutic methods, regardless of their social or financial condition. To find out, contact us.
FAQs
Is ICL or LASIK more painful?
Both ICL and LASIK surgeries are virtually painless. During each procedure, anaesthetic eye drops numb the eyes completely. After LASIK, patients may experience mild dryness or irritation for a few days, while ICL patients might feel slight pressure or light sensitivity. Any post-surgery discomfort is temporary and manageable.
Is ICL 100% safe?
ICL surgery is considered very safe when performed by an experienced ophthalmic surgeon. The implantable lens is biocompatible, meaning it adapts well to the eye without causing irritation. However, as with any eye surgery, minor risks—like infection, cataract development, or increased eye pressure—exist but are extremely rare with proper care.
Is ICL more expensive than LASIK?
Yes, ICL is more expensive than LASIK due to the cost of the implantable Collamer lens and the complexity of the procedure. While LASIK generally costs between ₹40,000–₹80,000 per eye, ICL ranges from ₹1,00,000–₹1,80,000 per eye. The higher cost reflects its reversibility, precision, and suitability for thin corneas.
Is ICL as good as LASIK?
Yes, in many cases, ICL is as good as, or even better than LASIK, especially for patients with thin corneas or high refractive errors. ICL provides sharper vision quality, faster recovery, and minimal dryness. However, LASIK remains an excellent choice for suitable candidates seeking a more affordable, non-invasive option.
Is LASIK 100% successful?
While LASIK has an impressive success rate of over 95–98%, no surgery is 100% guaranteed. Most patients achieve 20/20 or near-perfect vision. Minor residual refractive errors or temporary side effects like glare or halos can occur but typically resolve within a few months with proper post-operative care.
ICL or LASIK- Which Is Best?
Choosing between ICL vs LASIK depends on individual factors like corneal thickness, prescription strength, and eye health. LASIK suits most people with healthy corneas, while ICL is ideal for those with thin corneas, dry eyes, or high myopia. A detailed ophthalmic evaluation determines which procedure offers the best long-term results.
